A Rude, A Prude, and an Unsolved Mystery · Brown and Easter

Unsolved Mysteries Episode Ten: The Murder of Charlie Sigmin & Updates on the deaths of Don Henry & Kevin Ives

·1 hr 8 min·5 clips

Charlie opens the vegetable shed door to find Anne in a negligee, surrounded by candles, chanting to a Satan poster on the wall.

The week starts messy. Before the murder recap settles in, the Prude is already venting about school stress, teacher appreciation, QR-code gift lists, and workplace tension where every small exchange feels charged. Then the show changes gears hard. A joking crisis story about a phone and locking a door gives way to Charlie ignoring his gut and going unarmed anyway. The hosts cannot get past the setup. He thought something was wrong, he still went to Gary's house, and that decision sits over the whole case. Ann reports the shooting. Patrolman Hillburn's crime-scene description makes the house feel less suspicious than brutal: blood on the walls and door, bullet holes, and signs of a fight. The details knock the hosts off balance. They react to the wounds with stunned repetition instead of tidy solemnity, because the violence sounds frantic and messy. Their read is direct. To them, it sounds like a close-range fight, with shots fired while people were moving and struggling. Still, they keep pulling the focus back to the setup. The bullet paths matter, but so does the idea that Charlie may have been lured inside. The case talk stays jagged. They mock awkward phrasing, interrupt themselves, chase tangents, then casually drag the recap back into place. The ending wanders too. A childhood fear of bugs turns into a bleakly funny spider story about wanting Mimi's love, then a fake Talkspace sponsor bit slides into therapy jokes. Ridiculous, grim, ridiculous again. That is the rhythm here: couch-recapping an old mystery, laughing at the presentation, and still catching the moments when the facts are awful.

As heard by us

A messy, funny, grim recap that keeps the case at the center.

The episode opens in school-week chaos, then shifts into a grim account of Charlie Sigmin's murder and the details around it. The hosts keep things loose and reactive, which gives the discussion a lived-in feel instead of a polished one, and their disbelief lands hardest when…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Want a ragged, funny, grim rundown of Charlie's shooting and the unsolved-mystery updates?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from A Rude, A Prude, and an Unsolved Mystery