#783 StPO 197: Wann darf der Staat mit Zwangsmassnahmen in dein Leben eingreifen?

·16 min·1 clip

In 1913, a Tour de France leader repaired his bike mid-race; now, we explore when the state can forcibly intervene in your life.

The episode begins with a historical analogy about a 1913 Tour de France cyclist repairing his bike, symbolizing the resilience needed when facing state intervention. It then introduces Article 197 of the Swiss Code of Criminal Procedure, focusing on compulsory measures that allow the state to secretly or openly intervene in basic rights. The host explains that these measures require a legal basis, as per the first clause of Article 497.1, and critiques police creativity that bypasses this, such as using automated face recognition without proper authorization. A key theme is the lack of transparency in law enforcement actions, exemplified by PIM-1 requests and data comparisons. The discussion highlights the immense power of state attorneys and the need for stronger judicial control, mentioning an upcoming topic on judges' prevention systems. It delves into the vague legal standard of 'sufficient suspicion of crime,' noting its subjectivity and correlation with the severity of rights interventions. The Federal Court's French decision (1B-153-2020) is cited, emphasizing 'serieux et concrète' indications. The episode also covers proportionality, arguing that compulsory measures must use the least intrusive means, like preferring account editions over house searches for financial crimes. It questions the application of these measures to minor offenses, such as house searches for stolen perfume bottles. The host expresses personal concern about the abundance of compulsory measures and weak oversight. The conversation concludes by noting that measures involving non-guilty persons are particularly restrictive, requiring clear suspicion and purpose. Throughout, the format is an interview-style dialogue, with the host guiding the analysis of legal principles and real-world examples.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Auf dem Weg als Anwält:in