782. Enkelband vs cel: wat werkt beter?

·14 min·1 clip

Criminal law scientist Jacques Claassen reveals that half of prisoners reoffend within two years, calling prison an expensive way to make people worse.

The episode features criminal law scientist Jacques Claassen from Maastricht University discussing alternatives to prison sentences. He begins by noting that most Dutch prisoners serve short sentences averaging five months, with only 10% exceeding a year. Claassen states that prison sentences have a 50% recidivism rate within two years, calling them "an expensive way to make people worse." He introduces rehabilitation law as a different approach to justice that focuses on restoring damage rather than punishment. Rehabilitation law emphasizes cooperation between all parties involved—suspect, victim, and community—to address the needs of everyone affected by crime. Claassen contrasts this with traditional criminal law, which he says emerged historically not from civilization but from power struggles, citing Napoleon's influence. He points to traditional cultures like Aboriginal Australians, Maori in New Zealand, and Maroons in Suriname as examples of restorative justice practices where communities resolve conflicts through dialogue. The episode examines Norway's prison system, where recidivism is around 20% compared to 50% in the Netherlands, achieved through intensive rehabilitation programs. Claassen describes Norway's Bastoy prison island where prisoners have significant freedom and even operate the ferry for guards. He proposes electronic home detention as a middle-ground punishment between task sentences and prison for lighter crimes like minor violence, traffic offenses, and drug crimes. This would allow offenders to maintain jobs and education while being restricted to home except for one hour daily for essential activities. Claassen mentions a civil initiative bill he helped write that has been submitted to the Dutch parliament by parties including D66, CDA, and NSC. He notes current political divisions, with left-leaning parties supporting it and right-leaning parties opposing it. The episode concludes by connecting this to practical concerns about overcrowded Dutch prisons and staff shortages, suggesting alternatives could help address these systemic issues.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from De Universiteit van Nederland Podcast