Murder and Mysteries with Massnick · Kimberlie Massnick

Murders and Mysteries - Gerard John Schaefer

·31 min·2 clips

Technological advances and genealogical DNA are helping investigators revisit remains linked to Schaefer.

The episode starts with the hosts settling into their familiar joking rhythm. Kimberly Masnick welcomes listeners and jokes that some people may still be annoyed about the previous episode ending early. A stray flood headline briefly knocks the mood off course. After that, the conversation settles into Gerard Schaefer. They describe him as a man whose behavior leaves the hosts sounding genuinely appalled. The discussion turns to the roles he wanted for himself, including priest, school teacher, and cop. Those choices matter because each one would have put him in authority and around a lot of people. The hosts point out that this still does not make him fit a single easy profile. He does not neatly match one singular pattern or the triad image people expect. Even so, they can hear escalation in his behavior from a young age. They also push on the idea that the count most people know is too low. People they have spoken with in law enforcement and criminal justice believe the number could be at least three times higher. If that estimate is right, he belongs among the most prolific serial killers in U.S. history. And yet, very few people seem to know his name. The hosts keep the language plain and conversational while they work through all of this. They are comfortable saying when a theory is only a theory. They do not smooth over uncertainty just to make the story feel cleaner. They also keep bringing the focus back to victims, families, and why the case still matters. Near the end, they mention a student whose perspective could add something new. They finish by noting that at least one family member had been around Schaefer while he was an inmate, then stop short of giving the next layer away.

As heard by us

A searching Schaefer case study that resists neat answers.

Gerard John Schaefer is framed here as a case that does not fit clean serial-killer shorthand. Kimberly Masnick and her cohost keep pressing on the stubborn questions: what kind of man keeps reaching for authority roles, why the known pattern still feels unfinished, and why the…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a conversational deep dive into Gerard John Schaefer, with the hosts puzzling through how his commonly cited tally may understate the case.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Murder and Mysteries with Massnick