Murder and Mysteries with Massnick · Kimberlie Massnick

Murders and Mysteries - Gerard Schaefer

·32 min·5 clips

Dr. Kimberly Masnick opens the conversation with Mr. P-Cubed in their familiar back-and-forth style. They start with a little teasing, then move quickly into the case. The focus is Gerard Shaver and the people around him who may still have useful memories. They talk about outreach they have already made through Web Sleuths and social media. They also mention that they are asking listeners for help. The hosts frame family, friends, coworkers, and other associates as people who may hold important pieces of the story. That includes people from Shaver’s earlier life. They even raise the question of what he was like in late middle school and high school. The discussion leans into the problem of separating fact from performance. Shaver is described as someone who told so many stories that it becomes hard to tell what is real. The hosts keep testing the difference between a fact, an exaggeration, and a straight-up lie. They talk about how even lies can contain a grain of truth. That brings them back to the idea of him as a master manipulator. They also consider whether his anger toward women was broad or tied to a specific person. His siblings come up as the people most likely to know what really happened at home. The hosts discuss whether his father favored his sister or whether Shaver simply perceived it that way. They acknowledge that he may have blamed others for what shaped him. The episode also touches on prior contacts with people directly tied to him. Some conversations are clearly more valuable than others. One source is described as not professional and not credible enough to use. Another woman is mentioned more positively and as generous with her discussion. The episode closes with a practical request. They want advice on how to approach older people who may not want to revisit painful memories. The tone stays careful, informal, and focused on not causing avoidable harm. It is less about solving the case outright than about widening the circle of people who might help.

As heard by us

A cautious, human search for truth around a manipulator who left too many shadows behind.

This episode stays with the hard human work around Gerard: not just the case itself, but the people who knew him, were shaped by him, or still carry fragments of the story.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want the clues that still live in people, not just paperwork.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Murder and Mysteries with Massnick