Murder and Mysteries with Massnick · Kimberlie Massnick

Murders and Mysteries - Gerard Schaefer

·26 min·1 clip

A YouTube tour can be a hundred yards off from the actual body location.

1. Murder and Mysteries with Mastnick returns to the Gerard Schaefer case after a pause, with Dr. Kimberly Mastnick and Mr. P-Cubed revisiting work tied to the Cold Case Institute. 2. Dr. Kimberly Mastnick is the host and teacher, and Mr. P-Cubed is her collaborator because both have spent years on the Schaefer file. 3. The episode asks what happens when students, newspapers.com, and public records are used to build a case that has stayed obscure for years. 4. Mastnick says she first got interested in Gerard Schaefer as a college student and has held onto the case for decades. 5. The hosts say they want to give faces to the items on their board and return something to families who are still living. 6. They discuss how the case has not been mainstream, which they connect to the victims also being less known. 7. Mastnick describes sharing the case with her class during a political year when many sheriffs were running for election. 8. The students reportedly became fascinated because the case was in their backyard and because they could make a real difference. 9. Mastnick says the class is learning to speak with detectives, ask questions, and think like investigators rather than guessers. 10. Mr. P-Cubed brings up safety practices such as using the program email address, not personal social media, and avoiding direct exposure. 11. The hosts compare casework to checking a paper for errors, because a first read can miss obvious problems. 12. They say students are learning to strip away assumptions and follow facts wherever they lead. 13. The episode revisits a mapped island site and a 300-foot tape measure used to confirm where law enforcement had placed body locations. 14. Mastnick says some YouTube videos placed the site about 100 yards away, which matters when the search is for human remains. 15. The hosts describe walking through thorns, heat, and narrow paths until the landscape matched the documented map. 16. Mastnick says the students reacted strongly because they were standing at a final resting place, not just studying a file. 17. The tone is conversational and self-aware, with frequent back-and-forth between Mastnick and P-Cubed. 18. The format mixes teaching, case discussion, and recurring jokes about the Spanish fort, VPNs, and Siri. 19. Listeners interested in cold cases, forensic education, and student investigations. 20. Listeners wanting a polished true-crime recap with a finished ending.

As heard by us

A patient return to Gerard Schaefer that keeps the research, the families, and the facts in view.

This episode circles back to Gerard Schaefer with the kind of long memory that comes from years of sitting with a case. The hosts explain why they wanted to revisit it, why they want to put faces back on the trophies and question marks, and why the work still matters when…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a Gerard Schaefer revisit that treats research like a responsibility.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Murder and Mysteries with Massnick