Shayla of The Week #174- Standard and Daylight Savings Time: Mincha in The Fall and Winter VS. Minchah in The Spring and Summer- Everything You Need To Know about Davening Minchah Properly

·30 min·2 clips

Rabbi Walter explains why the winter's short window for Mincha prayer makes it the most challenging daily service.

Rabbi Moshe Walter opens by highlighting the practical challenge of the shortened time for Mincha prayer in the fall and winter months. He establishes the paramount importance of Mincha, citing a Talmudic statement that one must be exceptionally careful with it, as the prophet Elijah was answered specifically during Mincha. The host explains that Mincha is called such because Elijah was answered then, and it is likened to the Neilah service of Yom Kippur as the day's closing seal. He outlines the earliest permissible time for Mincha, known as Mincha Gedolah, beginning at six and a half halachic hours into the day. The ideal time is Mincha Ketanah, starting at nine and a half hours. A key technical discussion follows on calculating these times using 'sh'os z'manios,' or seasonal halachic hours, which vary in length between summer and winter. Rabbi Walter notes a minority opinion from Rabbi Moshe Feinstein and the Telshe Yeshiva custom that permits starting Mincha a fixed 30 minutes after midday, not based on halachic hours. The episode then addresses the latest time for Mincha, presenting the classic dispute between Rabbi Yehuda (until Plag HaMincha) and the Rabbonim (until nightfall). The Shulchan Aruch's position is explained: one must adopt a consistent approach and cannot mix the leniencies of both opinions, a concept known as 'tartei d'sasrei.' The host details the practical ruling of the Mishnah Berurah, which insists Mincha must be completed before sunset (sh'kiah), even if it means praying individually rather than with a quorum after sunset. He contrasts this with Hasidic communities that follow the Shulchan Aruch and Rama's more lenient view allowing Mincha after sunset. The discussion covers the custom of a shortened Mincha service without a repetition of the Amidah, explaining its basis in yeshivas due to concerns about bitul Torah (interruption of Torah study). Rabbi Walter mentions Rabbi Yaakov Kamenetzky's suggestion that the requirement for a full repetition might be relaxed for Mincha due to the day's busyness. The episode concludes with notes on starting Mincha with Ashrei, the importance of juxtaposing Ashrei and the Amidah, and reciting Tachanun. Rabbi Walter summarizes the key points: the importance and reward of Mincha, the use of halachic hours for timing, the preference for Mincha Ketanah, the Mishnah Berurah's strict sunset deadline, and the rules about consistency between Mincha and Ma'ariv times.

As heard by us

A clear, practical look at how shorter days affect the proper window for Mincha.

The episode follows a practical shift many regular daveners feel as summer gives way to fall and winter: Mincha no longer sits in a wide, easy afternoon window.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Need to know why Mincha feels tighter once the days shorten, and how late the window can run?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Rabbi Moshe Walter's Podcast