Relationship Whys Podcast · Terall & Tasia

Is Sinner the Best Movie of 2025?

·1 hr 3 min·4 clips

Preacher Boy's guitar both summons danger and becomes the weapon that ends it.

They open by saying there are a few different breakdowns and a few different things to go over. The point, they say, is to give the movie their own spin instead of just following the crowd. They ask listeners what they thought, whether they liked it, or whether they thought it was trash. They also ask whether some Christians pushed back because of the African spirituality around it. That sets up a deeper conversation rather than a plain yes-or-no review. They start with the characters, and Annie gets a lot of attention. She is described as a Black Southern woman and a witch-doctor figure, with the hosts reading her as symbolic as much as literal. The conversation leans hard into the movie's spiritual imagery. One host calls part of it very demonic and says that makes them sick. At the same time, they insist the symbolism mirrors what is happening in the world, not just what is happening on screen. Bible language comes up quickly. So does the idea that demon talk gets tangled up with fear of the unknown. They push back on the habit of calling everything evil just because it is unfamiliar. The hosts draw a firm line on practices they would never touch, like a Ouija board. They joke that if somebody tried to pull them into that space, they would leave. They also say they like being educated about these topics. Scary movies, they admit, are comfort viewing for them. That does not make them demonic, and they say so plainly. From there, they praise the movie for pushing boundaries and for packing in angels, ancestors, voodoo, and a bigger good-versus-evil argument, while also calling out the hypocrisy of Christians who use the label but live in ways they see as evil. The ending keeps the door open for a follow-up, especially with questions about Sax and Mary and whether there is more to pull apart.

As heard by us

A loose, direct faith and film debate that treats horror symbolism as serious material.

The episode is blunt and lively, moving from African spirituality to Annie's symbolic role without smoothing out the edges. Its strength is the momentum: the talk shifts from jokes to faith without sounding staged, and that gives it a lived-in feel.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a faith-and-film debate that gets blunt, weird, and personal fast.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Relationship Whys Podcast