11/18/25 Barry Eisler on the CIA, Venezuela and Using Novels to Wake People Up

·1 hr 3 min·5 clips

Eisler argues it's unique in American politics for lawmakers to openly pledge devotion to a foreign country's welfare.

1. Scott Horton interviews Barry Eisler, a former CIA officer turned novelist and Substack writer at The Heart of the Matter, about his shift from a conventional pro-American worldview to sharp critique of U.S. foreign policy. 2. Eisler describes joining the CIA in 1989 with mainstream establishment views, and says reading Glenn Greenwald's early blog roughly 20 years ago was a turning point. 3. The episode's core question is how someone trained inside the national-security establishment came to see U.S. foreign policy the way outside critics do. 4. Eisler says his three years at the CIA, from 1989 to 1992, were spent mostly on training and Japan-desk work, not covert operations, during the Gulf War and Soviet collapse. 5. He cites a British comedy sketch of Nazi soldiers asking are we the baddies as a device for questioning whether any nation's self-image as the good guys survives real scrutiny. 6. Eisler argues the current push toward war with Venezuela follows the same pattern as Iraq and Libya: vague justifications, a large naval buildup including the carrier Gerald Ford, and no formal declaration of war. 7. He names Chevron and Citgo as companies already profiting from existing Venezuelan oil access, while suggesting Exxon-linked funding of a think tank has pushed for regime change instead. 8. Eisler raises an unverified claim that Israeli concerns about Maduro's ties to Hezbollah, and Iranian grocery investment in sanctioned Venezuela, may factor into the push for regime change. 9. He compares the Venezuela buildup to NATO's expansion after the Soviet collapse, citing George Kennan's 1997 prediction that pushing military alliances toward Russia's border would provoke exactly the reaction it eventually got in Ukraine. 10. Eisler argues that solutions which worsen the underlying problem, like sanctions provoking closer Iran-Venezuela ties, then justifying further escalation, form a recurring pattern in U.S. foreign policy. 11. He argues it's unusual for American politicians to publicly pledge devotion to a foreign government's welfare, contrasting this with how Chinese leaders don't do the same for other countries. 12. Eisler distinguishes between people who reflexively call criticism of Israeli government policy antisemitic out of programmed defensiveness, calling it clinical, and those who do so cynically to intimidate critics. 13. He argues that responding to an argument with an accusation, rather than engaging it, should itself be read as a sign of the accuser's own weak position. 14. Eisler credits comedian George Carlin's skepticism of government as a foundational influence, describing showing Carlin's routines to his daughter as a deliberate antidote to school-taught inculcation. 15. He argues Americans rarely notice how unusual their government's constant unauthorized bombing of other countries looks from abroad, drawing on his own years living in Japan and Brazil. 16. Eisler pushes back on commentator Van Jones's description of Iran as bizarre, arguing the label better fits America's own foreign-policy behavior. 17. The conversation is a long, discursive two-person interview, with Eisler giving extended personal reflections and Horton steering the discussion toward current events. 18. The tone is candid and self-critical, with Eisler frequently acknowledging his own past establishment assumptions rather than presenting himself as having always known better. 19. Listeners interested in foreign-policy critique, media analysis, or first-person reflections from a former intelligence officer will find this valuable. 20. Listeners looking for insider CIA operational stories rather than political analysis should skip it, since Eisler says his tour involved little of that.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Scott Horton Show - Just the Interviews