9/5/25 William Van Wagenen on the Origins of the Arab Spring and Syrian Civil War

·1 hr 38 min·5 clips

A former ISIS and al-Qaeda commander, installed as Syria's president, met a smiling President Trump in Saudi Arabia within months.

1. This is a return interview on the Scott Horton Show with investigative journalist William Van Wagenen about his book 'Creative Chaos: Inside the CIA's Covert War to Topple the Syrian Government.' 2. Host Scott Horton, of the Libertarian Institute and Antiwar.com, interviews Van Wagenen, who reports on the ground in Syria and previously discussed the Iraq War with Horton. 3. The episode's core argument is that the 2011 Syrian uprising was not a spontaneous popular revolt but a planned covert operation with roots going back decades. 4. Van Wagenen traces early plans to figures like Farid Ghadry, a Syrian exile he says was recruited by neoconservatives Richard Perle, Victoria Nuland, Scooter Libby, and David Wormser as a potential post-Assad leader. 5. He says the motive mirrors the 2003 Iraq War: weakening Iran's regional alliance with Syria and Hezbollah on behalf of Israel, per Wormser's 'Clean Break' strategy of dividing Syria and Iraq into ethnic ministates. 6. Van Wagenen explains that Syria's Alawite minority, roughly 10% of the population, held outsized influence in the security forces while the Sunni merchant class in Aleppo and Damascus held most economic power. 7. He says Salafist hostility toward Alawites, rooted in medieval scholar Ibn Taymiyyah's fatwas branding them apostates, was exploited by outside powers including al-Qaeda and Islamic State sponsors to fuel sectarian conflict. 8. He traces the tactic to 1979-1982, when the U.S., Jordan, and Israel armed a Muslim Brotherhood insurgency in Syria that culminated in the Hama uprising and its violent suppression by Hafez al-Assad. 9. Van Wagenen cites Presidential Study Directive 11 from September 2010, involving the CIA, State Department, and tech companies, which he says set policy to install Muslim Brotherhood governments across Tunisia, Yemen, Egypt, and Syria. 10. He describes how rebel factions in Aleppo, allegedly directed by Turkish intelligence, destroyed the city's historic markets and looted factories, alienating the Sunni majority who did not welcome them. 11. He says opposition commanders themselves acknowledged in interviews, including with The Guardian, that roughly 70 percent of Aleppo's population opposed the rebels. 12. Van Wagenen and Horton discuss how the Muslim Brotherhood, which Van Wagenen calls a historical creation of British intelligence, was positioned by the U.S. to take power in multiple Arab Spring countries. 13. They discuss the 1982 Hama massacre in detail, noting disputed casualty figures ranging from a U.S. intelligence estimate of 2,000 to the Muslim Brotherhood's claim of 20,000. 14. Van Wagenen argues that Western governments continued backing al-Qaeda's Nusra Front and ISIS in Syria throughout the war while publicly denying it. 15. He notes that when former ISIS and al-Qaeda commander Abu Muhammad al-Jolani took power in December, Britain and the U.S. recognized him almost immediately and dropped his bounty within months. 16. He recounts Jolani, later rebranded as 'al-Sharaa,' meeting and shaking hands with President Trump in Saudi Arabia. 17. The conversation is a long-form, source-heavy interview, with Horton pressing for documentary evidence and Van Wagenen citing declassified cables, CIA documents, and on-the-ground interviews. 18. The tone is investigative and openly adversarial toward official Western and Israeli narratives about the Syrian war. 19. Listeners interested in Middle East geopolitics, CIA covert operations, and revisionist accounts of the Arab Spring would value this episode. 20. Listeners looking for mainstream consensus reporting on Syria or uninterested in dense historical detail may want to skip it.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Scott Horton Show - Just the Interviews