The History Network · The History Network

The Treason of Benedict Arnold - Part 2

·23 min·2 clips

Benedict Arnold delivers a fiery courtroom defense of his patriotism, all while actively betraying his country to the British.

This episode, written by historian Michael Gaby Gross, continues the story of Benedict Arnold's betrayal during the American Revolution. It details Arnold's growing resentment and the secret negotiations that led him to switch sides. The narrative focuses on Arnold's conflict with political rivals, his courtship of loyalist Peggy Shippen, and his clandestine correspondence with British Major John André. Arnold faced a court-martial for profiteering and misuse of power while serving as military governor of Philadelphia. His political enemy, Joseph Reed of Pennsylvania's Supreme Executive Council, led the charges against him. Arnold defended himself vigorously, citing his heroic military record from Quebec to Saratoga, and the court acquitted him of most charges, issuing only a minor reprimand. George Washington personally delivered this reprimand, urging Arnold to regain the esteem of his country. Arnold interpreted this public letter as a profound humiliation and a victory for his enemies. He subsequently sought command of the strategic fort at West Point to offer it to the British. John André, head of British spy networks and an aide to General Henry Clinton, negotiated with Arnold for his betrayal. The British initially demanded Arnold acquire a field command to lead troops into a trap, but Arnold proposed instead to surrender the undermanned West Point garrison. Arnold sold his home in New Haven and secretly inspected West Point's weak fortifications, reporting them to the British. Washington initially offered Arnold command of the army's left wing, but Arnold's visible disappointment led Washington to give him the West Point command instead. Arnold then worked to isolate the fort, dispersing troops and moving his headquarters to a secluded loyalist mansion. A planned secret meeting between Arnold and André went awry when American cannon fire drove André's ship, the Vulture, away, stranding André behind American lines. André was captured carrying hidden plans of West Point and a pass signed by Arnold, under the alias John Anderson. Upon learning of the capture, Arnold immediately fled to the British warship Vulture, leaving his wife Peggy behind. British General Clinton was more concerned for André's fate than welcoming Arnold, and he pleaded with Washington for André's life. Washington offered to exchange André for Arnold, but Clinton refused, leading to André's execution as a spy. The episode ends with Arnold safely with the British while the Americans discover his treason. The tone is educational and narrative, presenting a detailed chronological account of the conspiracy. The style is descriptive, drawing from historical letters and biographies to illustrate the characters' motivations and the plot's escalating tension. Listeners interested in military history, personal drama, and intricate tales of betrayal will find this episode compelling. Those seeking broad overviews of historical periods rather than deep, single-story dives might find the detail too granular.

As heard by us

Arnold's fall turns Revolutionary War history into a court martial and spy drama.

Benedict Arnold's rise and collapse carry this chapter. It moves through battlefield reputation, money troubles, and wounded pride as each one closes off another path. What starts as wartime ambition ends in hearings, charges, and a quiet turn toward secret loyalty.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play for Benedict Arnold's rise, disgrace, and the chain reaction that ends with Andre.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The History Network